Upper Keys: Key Largo and Islamorada
Alabama Jack's
An open-air bar and grill on the old road into the Keys, known for conch fritters and weekend music.
Islamorada Fish Company
Waterfront fish house with feeding of the tarpon and huge sunset views.
Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar
Bayside sunset bar with live music most nights.
Mrs. Mac's Kitchen
Key Largo's long-running local diner, with license plates on the walls.
Middle Keys: Marathon
Keys Fisheries
A working fish market with a casual restaurant. Try the lobster Reuben.
Key West
Blue Heaven
Eat under the trees with chickens wandering by. Famous for its sky-high key lime pie.
El Siboney
Generous, inexpensive Cuban plates in a corner restaurant.
Louie's Backyard
Oceanfront dining and a bar right over the water.
Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe
Key lime pie, frozen and dipped in chocolate on a stick.
Hogfish Bar & Grill
Working-waterfront fish shack, known for its hogfish sandwich.
Restaurants open, close, move and change hours often. Check the restaurant's own website or call before you go. No restaurant paid to be listed.
Key West food tours and sunset dinner sails
Viator
Viator
Viator
Viator
Viator
Viator
Viator
ViatorTours and tickets from our partner Viator. Prices are from-prices in USD and can change. We may earn a commission when you book, at no extra cost to you.
Driving the Keys?
Compare Key West hotel deals at Rooms Cheap, rent a car in Miami at USA Auto Rental, and see 101 Things to Do in the Keys and Best of the Keys for things to do.
Frequently asked questions
Is key lime pie supposed to be green?
No. Real key lime pie is pale yellow. Key lime juice and egg yolks make it yellow; green pies use food coloring.
What is hogfish?
A mild, sweet reef fish caught by spearfishing in the Keys, often served as a sandwich or fried.